Back to top

‘We are going to push back when they attempt to roll out policies that threaten people’s accessibility to the care that they need,’ says new CEO Carl Baloney, Jr.

Coming into a leadership role right now in an HIV organization is no small feat. Since January of this year, this second Trump administration has unraveled decades’ worth of work by advocates, researchers and service providers to scale up access to treatment and prevention programs including new long-acting options for people not wanting daily pill treatment or PrEP. In late August, several leaders at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (including a noted HIV champion) quit the agency in protest over Health and Human Services secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s stacking vaccine advisory panels with vaccine deniers and others holding unscientific views on medical science.

Onto this field, Carl Baloney, Jr., has stepped up to bat. The New Orleans native, who spent the past decade in the policy department at AIDS United, one of the leading policy advocacy groups, before becoming its vice president, was announced this summer as the new president and CEO of the organization. In his new role, Baloney will help fund local efforts while advocating at the federal level for funding and effective policy.

Baloney began his career in the U.S. House of Representatives, where he served as a staffer for then-Congressman Charlie Melancon of Louisiana. Later, he moved to Planned Parenthood Federation of America as senior manager of legislative affairs, where he built strategic partnerships with policymakers to expand access to reproductive health care. In 2015, he transitioned to AIDS United, taking the helm of its federal advocacy efforts, shaping the organization’s policy agenda through strategic collaboration.

I spoke with Baloney about his life, what led him to this moment and what he sees as today’s challenges and future opportunities to still end the epidemic.

Kenyon Farrow: What is your origin story of coming into your work as a policy expert and an advocate in the HIV and public health field?

Carl Baloney, Jr.: I’m from New Orleans, born and raised. In Louisiana, we have parishes instead of counties. My family is from an area known as the River Parishes, specifically Saint John the Baptist Parish. That area is also called “Cancer Alley.” My family were in private business work for themselves and rooted in communities. And because of where we were and the privilege that we carried, my family became activists.

I remember early on a petrochemical company was going to put a plant right smack dab in the middle of the community where my father grew up. No surprise, it was an unincorporated community that was probably more than 90% Black and poor. They were folks who came off of the plantation, and so the petrochemical company did not expect to meet any resistance. But my father organized the community and rallied them to push back. After a long fight and a lot of protests, they were able to get the plant to relocate elsewhere.

My father still died of cancer growing up in that area. So many people there die of cancer at much higher rates than the national prevalence. But I think those early opportunities, seeing them fighting back for their communities, made me want to engage in policy, politics and activism and supporting communities. That’s really where it starts for me.

Thinking about HIV, specifically, it was my time at Planned Parenthood. I handled their sex education policy portfolio. Through that, I learned about this thing called PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis) in 2011 and I thought, “This is wild. I’m a Black gay man from the South and I am the target population. I’ve never heard of this. Why? Why is this the case?” You know, I’m a professional in public health in many ways, and so I got really fascinated by it. I did as much as I could to learn more about PrEP, its access, its affordability, who could access it, and how Planned Parenthood at that time wasn’t doing a whole lot around PrEP access.

I started talking to our medical affairs folks and our sex education national policy folks, figuring out how we can support integrating that into our model to make sure that as many people could access it as possible. The more I learned and talked to people, it lit a fire in me around HIV. And then this opportunity at AIDS United came about to apply to be director of government affairs, and I jumped on it and the rest is history.

Hearing you reflect on learning about PrEP made me think about my entry point to the HIV space. About eight years before PrEP was approved, a bunch of my Black and Puerto Rican friends began disclosing to me they were living with HIV. I was already doing activism work, but it became clear to me that I needed to come to HIV in terms of the work.

I totally hear all of that.

Given that PrEP was approved in 2012, what do you think about how far we’ve come? Have we made progress in those 13 years?

I’m amazed and thrilled for the people that have been able to regularly access and afford PrEP. It’s wonderful. But again, the same people who have petrochemical companies foisted upon their communities are the same population as your friends who were disclosing their status to you in the early aughts. They are the same population who are not increasing uptake of PrEP or not being able to access it or afford it. And that’s really disconcerting.

It’s such a simple solution. It’s with insurance coverage and the advances made through the ACA (Affordable Care Act). It should be affordable for most. There’s really no excuse in a country like this for people to not know about it. There’s no excuse for people who know about it to not be able to access it and afford it. And it doesn’t even make financial sense for the nation. Even if you take the heart out of it, it doesn’t make financial sense. It’s bad public health policy for folks not to be able to access it without limitations. So I want to say it’s unbelievable, but it also follows long trends of this country not taking care of her most vulnerable. It’s unfortunate.

Speaking of a country not taking care of its most vulnerable, we’re having this interview just after the Health and Human Service secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. announced changes that make it harder for people who are under the age of 65 to get their annual COVID-19 vaccine and fired Susan Monarez, PhD, the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, even though he says she resigned. This led to a number of division directors at the CDC resigning en masse, including Demetri Daskalakis, MD, a long friend of the community who wrote a scathing letter about what was happening in terms of not following science and politicizing the CDC’s work.

What is your perspective on what’s happening in this political environment where so much progress is under threat?

At least 1.2 million people died of COVID-19 in the United States. We have amazing biomedical interventions that help keep people safe and healthy. Be it PrEP for prevention of HIV or the COVID-19 vaccine for prevention of COVID-19, they’re effective, they’re trusted, and they should be accessible to all. I can’t begin to fathom the administration’s motives for pulling back on accessibility to those interventions. It will not save the federal government money, which is often touted as their chief priority. It will not make people healthier. It’ll hurt Americans. I don’t think there is any rationale that could satisfy the sense behind it. I think it’s important that folks speak up and speak out against shifts in policy that are going to harm people.

Whether the head of the CDC was fired or whether she resigned, I think it’s important that folks in positions of power use their voice to stand by the accessibility of these interventions and science. As it relates to Dr. Daskalakis, I think it’s important that he lives his truth. And if he is not in agreement with what they’re doing, he needs to speak up about it. And that’s what he’s done. I appreciate that, because folks in positions of power are the ones whose voices are most likely to be heard and to sway public opinion. Folks who need the COVID-19 shot or the everyday American who needs PrEP accessibility are not being heard. And I think the important thing is to trust science and trust medicine. Right?

Trying to sow disbelief in the efficacy of these tested and proven interventions creates a chilling effect between people and their doctors. And it’s important that people be able to trust medicine and trust doctors. And this is not it. That’s not how we become a healthier society.

How do you see AIDS United’s role in terms of responding to this political crisis, and what’s your vision for taking AIDS United past this moment?

Frankly, my vision is centered in equity, audacious advocacy, leadership and bold investment in the communities we serve. AU, in some form or fashion, has been around for the better part of 35 years. We were formed through the merger of the National AIDS Fund and the AIDS Action Council, and since the beginning of the epidemic, we have fought and helped to shape policy with the members of our public policy council, through our grant making and investments in community, and our leadership development and capacity building technical assistance.

I think that we have the right pillars. I know that we have the community’s trust. And that’s been earned through hard work. I’m so proud of our staff. We have a staff that comes from the community and that centers community in everything that we do, and we’re going to continue that. I really want to build on that commitment to justice and health equity through our work. I think this is a moment where we really need to come in coalition to solve this problem. And it’s not just a coalition of HIV advocates and community-based organizations and HIV. We need to look at the broader progressive movement including healthcare, health equity, LGBTQ rights and justice. We’re at a time where we’re called to break down the silos and work together. Because whether or not we’re centered on the same issues, we all have the same commitment. And that’s accessibility to health, rights and the well-being of the communities that we come from.

AIDS United has a set of grants that focus on Deep South states, harm reduction for injection drug use, women and Black gay men. All of these communities are facing policies and legislation at the state and federal level that are mean spirited.

How are you working with organizations that are still committed to that work? Because we’re seeing organizations that are capitulating and scrubbing their websites or ending various kinds of programs in order to appease the administration.

That’s a big question. We are going to always center the most marginalized, impacted communities who need our help. That’s not something we can walk away from. It’s not good business, it’s not good sense, and it’s not how we get to end the epidemic. And our priority is to end the epidemic in the United States. Period. Full stop.

It doesn’t matter who you are, where you come from, what you look like or what you worship. It does not matter. We want to make sure that people have access to quality health care and the information that they need to lead healthy lives free of HIV or being virally suppressed and in treatment and able to be productive. That’s our mission. That’s our goal, and that’s how we’ll continue to go about the work.

I don’t think this is political. It’s just not. Healthcare is not political and the ability to live a long and healthy life should not be political. And that’s not a game we’re going to play. We are going to push back when they attempt to roll out policies that threaten people’s accessibility to the care that they need. But this is really simple for us. We’ll keep working in coalition, we’ll try to provide the resources and support that we can to community-based organizations that are providing care in their communities whilst under attack and we’ll try to provide the support that they need, that we can provide to the degree that we can provide it.

The point is: We’re not going anywhere. We intend to be in this fight for as long as it takes. Administrations come and go, but this community has stayed strong through all of it in a really tightknit and effective fashion that can’t be denied. I know I’m preaching to the choir here, but it took years for the words HIV and AIDS to be said out loud by our president or by policymakers. And this community made them do it. They made them bring resources to find medications and millions of folks are alive today because of that. Both here and many millions abroad on the backs of the advocates that built this community. And we’re going to stand next to them.

What do you wish was better resourced in the work?

I know what we can do. And I will invite and work to bring the community along with us. I think a major gap is in how we communicate about the need and this work. I mentioned everything that we’ve built on the backs of the early advocates, many of whom are still here in this fight. But that took strong coordination and planning and relentlessness. And we have been able to limit the deaths from HIV in this country. We have been able to be on a trend to reduce new infections across certain populations.

But in a lot of ways, I feel like we have become victims of our own success. The age of “HIV exceptionalism” is gone. And folks need to be reminded why HIV still matters, why HIV prevention matters and how this is still an issue. That goes for gay people and straight people. I think some gay people don’t think this is still an issue. And this is something that was once called a “gay disease,” which is why I’m referring specifically to gay people. It’s still an issue, right?

We need to build stronger, more effective communications that get the point across to the general public; to the gay man who’s on PrEP and is not worried about anybody else; and to policymakers who make the funding decisions to support people impacted by HIV and who need HIV prevention efforts. I think that’s one of the biggest charges I have: Helping to shape and build a better body of knowledge on how to communicate about the need to save ourselves.

 

 


From left: Carl Baloney, Jr., AIDS United; Ramon Gardenhire, ViiV Healthcare; Venita Gray, AIDS United and U.S. People Living With HIV Caucus; Ari, Equality Federation; Maryanne Tomazic, Harvard Law School Center for Health Law and Policy Innovation; D. Rashaan Gilmore, Blaqout; Michael Elizabeth, Equality Federation and U.S. People Living With HIV Caucus.

Five years from now, if you were able to look back, what are the things that you would say: “If we’re able to do this set of things, in five years, I will feel better about our trajectory on HIV in this country.”

If we’re able to develop tested, effective messaging that sways people, that speaks the truth in a way that is compelling and moving and able to disseminate that messaging to build up support for HIV treatment, care and prevention, we will have been successful. If we have been able to support communities in building the capacity to work on and fight for policies at the local level that will give them a leg up and support their ability to access treatment and prevention tools, we’ve been successful. If we have helped to thread the needle to rebuild the HIV advocacy framework, we will have been successful.

I know you’re talking about five years up, but when I think about the last eight months of this year, we as a community have spoken up and spoken out countless times against threats to our health and safety. And when we have felt most effective is when we have been the loudest and most coordinated. It’s when we have been in the press, in town halls, and in the offices. And we didn’t let harmful policies go by unanswered. That’s when we have been the strongest. And I think that’s been difficult. Because the community is a body. Right? And you have to feed a body, care for a body and look after the things that you have to do.

I believe that we have let some of our muscles atrophy in terms of activism. And we’re rebuilding those muscles. We’re moving and we’re starting to run. So I think if we can provide and support communities on strengthening those muscles and toning them, we’re going to be stronger. And I think we’ll be in a better place as it relates to ending the epidemic.

What’s the strategy to help the community build its muscles around different kinds of activism or advocacy tactics?

We have a playbook, and we try to stick to it. It’s effective. And the things you have to do, you have to tweak and work on them. We’re not the end-all, be-all. AIDSWatch is our national advocacy event. It is highly effective at mobilizing advocates. At the last AIDSWatch, we had over 650 folks attend. That’s amazing. Forty-six percent of those people are living with HIV, and their stories are the truth of what’s happening across the country.

We help the folks who come to AIDSWatch craft their personal stories and relate them to policy and to relay that to members of Congress and their staff. And we feel that’s highly effective. I think what’s missing is that AIDSWatch is a one-day event at the national level, and a lot of decisions that impact this happen back home in the districts and state house. We want to build on threading the needle between federal action and state action, and state engagement and activism.

We launched and have been piloting the past few years “AIDSWatch at Home,” where we support state-based groups in doing just that. That is something that I seek to expand in the coming years. Building up what services we can provide to help local organizations and local coalitions build up their advocacy and their organizing capacity. And hopefully, as I said earlier, they’ll also be able to thread the needle to other like-minded coalitions and networks related to or outside of HIV.

We’re at a time where we’re called to break down the silos and work together.

I’m curious about your thoughts on treatment access in this country. I’m sure a lot of folks living with HIV are concerned about what is happening to the Ryan White CARE Act. How is AIDS United working to protect the social safety net program for people living with HIV?

Ryan White’s a critical program for people living with HIV. I am cautiously optimistic about the program’s fate. Congress has predominantly level funded (approving the same dollar amount as the previous year, but not increasing funding to account for inflation) the Ryan White program. I think that’s a positive. While we know we need more resources, we’re in an environment where they’re cutting everything. So seeing Congress step up and level fund that program, for the most part, is very encouraging.

I think the Senate provided an increase to HOPWA—Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS—with HUD (Housing and Urban Development). So if we can continue to see a trend of members of Congress, regardless of party, staying committed to this funding, we should at least be able to maintain the status quo. Now, the status quo is not enough. Right? There are still people who are seroconverting who don’t have to. And there are still people whose HIV transitions to AIDS and who die. I’ll say that it is inexcusable in a country like this. But we’re going to keep up the advocacy and try to protect those core programs.

Folks also depend on Medicaid for access to coverage. And I’m worried about what states will do as they get pinched with a lack of federal resources to support their Medicaid programs. That’s why we’re going to be doubling down on our local and state-based efforts as well.

For the last eight years, there has been community concern around the use of molecular surveillance and data at CDC and the potential that that data could fall into the wrong hands or get used to further various kinds of HIV criminalization efforts. Can you talk about how AU is addressing HIV criminalization in this current environment?

Molecular surveillance and criminalization, at the very least, have a deep chilling effect on folks in their communities. HIV laws that criminalize folks with HIV status are despicable and should not exist anywhere. And that is something we’re definitely organizing to push back on. It’s a core priority as it relates to molecular surveillance. I know that strong data is important to tracking disease states, but it has to be handled responsibly and respectfully. And we definitely have to form systems in coordination with the impacted communities. I think the lack of community coordination is what’s really causing problems here. And we would definitely call upon policymakers and the feds to coordinate with experts and the folks who are impacted to develop systems that can work for both community and medical purposes.

What makes you hopeful during this period of time?

When we call upon the community to push back and we say, “They want to eliminate the HOPWA program—your center needs to hear from you, your local paper needs a write up about this, we have to expose this issue.” When we’ve made that call, folks have stopped and turned on the drop of a dime and fought back. And we’ve had some small successes when that has happened. So I think my hopefulness comes from the strength of this community.

I think we’re all tired of being resilient. But this community is so resilient, and we’re going to do what we need to do to live our lives. That’s where I gather strength from. I always say, AIDSWatch is my favorite part of the work because it is the closest that I come to direct service when I really get to talk to and [hold] fellowship with the folks who are on the ground every day. It gives me so much energy. USCHA (the U.S. Conference on HIV/AIDS, organized every year by the advocacy organization NMAC) is similar, right? It’s these spaces where we all come together and love each other and talk about solutions and challenges—[that’s] where I gather strength and where I gather encouragement.

What can folks expect from AIDS United in the coming months? And how can they work with you all?

I think if you’re a community-based organization, if you work at one or you lead one, and you’re not a part of the AIDS United Public Policy Council, you need to join. You know the old adage, “If you’re not at the table, you’re on the menu,” is true. The Public Policy Council has helped shape national HIV policy for the better part of three decades. We’re going to continue to do so, and we need your voices at the federal table here in Washington, D.C., when we can go to reimagine what the HIV care system is going to look like. Right now, lots of things are being dismantled. But we need to plan about what we’re going to build, and we need as many community voices as possible at that table. I think the other piece is, we want to support the community. Again, broken record. We are going to be in states and localities, expanding support for organizing and advocacy. But we can’t do that alone and we can’t actually lead it in your backyard. So join us in this fight, in shaping and rebuilding our local advocacy capacity if you’re able. That’s what we want to see. 

WATCH the unedited video of Kenyon Farrow’s conversation with AIDS United CEO Carl Baloney, Jr., on YouTube at bit.ly/pa-interview-carl-baloney-jr.